Thursday, March 13, 2025

Expert Front 1941: Mud and snow

 

It is August 31st, and one month of summer remains before the muddy rasputitsa and biting Russian winter. One month to make German superiority count. Let's do this.

 

Riga to Rzhev:

Axis Current
strength
Current
strength
USSR
10 Infantry Corps 55 74 41 Infantry Army
41 Panzer Corps 148

46 Panzer Corps 79 88 32 Infantry Army


80 30 Infantry Army
38 Infantry Corps 47 100 34 Infantry Army
40 Panzer Corps 188 42 4 Guards Infantry Army
1 Infantry Corps 74 60 1 Guards Cavalry Army
56 Panzer Corps 119 56 56 Infantry Army
28 Infantry Corps 85

2 Infantry Corps 107

 

The strength advantage here is decisively mine, but after my inevitable victory I will have a difficult choice to make - do I go after Leningrad, or not? Leningrad would be worth a few victory points and two Finnish infantry, but Smolensk needs help.


Minsk to Smolensk:

Axis Current
strength
Current
strength
USSR
7 Infantry Corps 145

26 Infantry Corps 93

4 Flieger Corps 231 108 31 Infantry Army
47 Panzer Corps 45 95 22 Infantry Army
6 Infantry Corps 102 11 29 Infantry Army
1 Flieger Corps 218



112 28 Infantry Army
24 Panzer Corps 65 52 2 Tank Army
8 Infantry Corps 59 137 40 Infantry Army
2 Flieger Corps 182



50 3 Cavalry Army


56 14 Infantry Army


57 21 Infantry Army
 

This looks bad. Three units near Smolensk are cut off from supplies and can do little but entrench while waiting for help, and only the 6th infantry is close enough to provide any immediate relief. I will have the 7th and 26th infantries detach from the northern group to help here.

 

Kiev:

Axis Current
strength
Current
strength
USSR
5 Infantry Corps 99 43 5 Tank Army


72 10 Infantry Army


59 18 Infantry Army


80 19 Infantry Army
3 Panzer Corps 141 77 23 Infantry Army
49 Infantry Corps 91

9 Infantry Corps 118

11 Infantry Corps 96

27 Infantry Corps 75

12 Infantry Corps 79

23 Infantry Corps 83

57 Panzer Corps 145

5 Flieger Corps 190

14 Panzer Corps 156 134 18 Tank Army
4 Infantry Corps 96

48 Panzer Corps 121 50 1 Cavalry Army
29 Infantry Corps 39

3 Flieger Corps 179


The 5th infantry is deep in the swamp, bravely holding off three Soviet units. There's little to impede the rest of my army here.

 

Odessa:

Axis Current
strength
Current
strength
USSR
17 Infantry Corps 45

30 Infantry Corps 95 8 4 Cavalry Army
1 Hungarian Panzer 29 24 5 Cavalry Army
54 Infantry Corps 53 70 2 Infantry Army
1 Rumanian Infantry 74

5 Rumanian Infantry 48 36 7 Infantry Army
2 Rumanian Infantry 62

4 Rumanian Infantry 28


My army here isn't in the best shape, but nonetheless I expect Odessa to fall soon, after which I can send them to other fronts.

 

September is a long, bloody month, and apart from Odessa, no additional cities are conquered. I even lose Kiev, though just for one turn, to the mud units behind me!

 

August 31 - October 4


Riga to Rzhev:

"Inevitable victory"


Axis Old
strength
Current
strength x2
Current
strength
Old
strength
USSR
10 Infantry Corps 55 30
74 41 Infantry Army
41 Panzer Corps 148 74 71
9 Militia Army



86
42 Infantry Army
46 Panzer Corps 79 104
88 32 Infantry Army



136 80 30 Infantry Army
38 Infantry Corps 47 22
100 34 Infantry Army
40 Panzer Corps 188 74
42 4 Guards Infantry Army



94
11 Militia Army
1 Infantry Corps 74 62
60 1 Guards Cavalry Army
56 Panzer Corps 119 104 66 56 56 Infantry Army
28 Infantry Corps 85 84 96
7 Militia Army
2 Infantry Corps 107 106 43
43 Infantry Army
35 Infantry Corps
94 104
43 Infantry Army


We destroyed the September squad pretty thoroughly, but this took longer and cost more muster than expected, and by October's mud, whatever we destroyed are more than replaced with reinforcements and militia. Leningrad must wait. Yes, there are two different 43 infantries; Russian numbering systems are very complicated.

 

Minsk to Smolensk:

Axis Old
strength
Current
strength x2
Current
strength
Old
strength
USSR
7 Infantry Corps 145 58


26 Infantry Corps 93 82


13 Infantry Corps
108


4 Flieger Corps 231 118
108 31 Infantry Army
47 Panzer Corps 45 102 69 95 22 Infantry Army
6 Infantry Corps 102 107
11 29 Infantry Army
34 Infantry Corps
96


1 Flieger Corps 218 218






112 28 Infantry Army
24 Panzer Corps 65 78 41 52 2 Tank Army
8 Infantry Corps 59 109 89 137 40 Infantry Army
2 Flieger Corps 182 183






50 3 Cavalry Army



21 56 14 Infantry Army



79 57 21 Infantry Army

The initial goal was to rescue the panzers and 8th infantry from the north Dnieper river, and very soon the goal also became to rescue an eager 7th infantry who pushed themselves into a kitty corner at the month's start. Overall the goal was a success, and the 8th infantry managed to escape their muddy deathtrap with a bit of air support, but nobody in this group is in great shape except the Fliegerkorps and the reinforcements.

 

Kiev to Kharkov:

Axis Old
strength
Current
strength x2
Current
strength
Old
strength
USSR
5 Infantry Corps 99 92 13 43 5 Tank Army




72 10 Infantry Army



42 59 18 Infantry Army




80 19 Infantry Army
3 Panzer Corps 141 52
77 23 Infantry Army



56
15 Infantry Army
49 Infantry Corps 91 80


9 Infantry Corps 118 108


11 Infantry Corps 96 91


27 Infantry Corps 75 77 94
60 Infantry Army
12 Infantry Corps 79 97


23 Infantry Corps 83 80 103
33 Infantry Army
57 Panzer Corps 145 145


5 Flieger Corps 190 132 114
66 Infantry Army
14 Panzer Corps 156 62
134 18 Tank Army
4 Infantry Corps 96 20 113
19 Tank Army
48 Panzer Corps 121 148 41 50 1 Cavalry Army
29 Infantry Corps 39 42


3 Flieger Corps 179 142



Impediment happened, as we're met by reinforcements near Kharkov. 5th infantry couldn't hold off three units alone for long, so I joined it with the 49th while the airplanes moved forward - now they've all moved east some and are holding onto Kiev.

The 14th Panzers tried to encircle a Russia tank army mid-September, but wound up walking right into a pincer trap, where it must remain all October now. This wouldn't have happened if we could play out the action day-by-day instead of week-by-week!

 

Odessa:

Axis Old
strength
Current
strength x2
Current
strength
Old
strength
USSR
17 Infantry Corps 45 88


30 Infantry Corps 95 98
8 4 Cavalry Army
1 Hungarian Panzer 29 36
24 5 Cavalry Army
54 Infantry Corps 53 45
70 2 Infantry Army
1 Rumanian Infantry 74 47


5 Rumanian Infantry 48 17
36 7 Infantry Army
2 Rumanian Infantry 62 35


4 Rumanian Infantry 28



4 Italian Infantry
54



It took all month, but the Romanian Suicide Squad took Odessa, killed everyone around it, and what's left of them are slowly walking away.

 

Fighting over the next month is futile - every Axis unit is working at half strength during the muddy season! As before, I keep some distance as I try to reform my lines on favorable terrain, but this is trickier than it was.

As winter starts, all of my Fliegerkorps are down a massive amount of combat strength, though none have suffered any permanent muster damage.


October 5 - November 8


Northmost cluster:


Axis Old
strength x2
Current
strength
Current
strength
Old
strength
USSR
10 Infantry Corps 30 31 80 71 9 Militia Army
28 Infantry Corps 84 20 36 96 7 Militia Army



82 86 42 Infantry Army
40 Panzer Corps 74 95 123 94 11 Militia Army
2 Infantry Corps 106 95 50 43 43 Infantry Army
41 Panzer Corps 74 83


 

These guys have mostly held it together throughout the mud season, and skirmished a bit with the Soviets nearby during the first week of winter, but aren't fully recovered yet. Strength advantage is overall mine, especially as the militia cannot attack.

 

Rzhev:

Axis Old
strength x2
Current
strength
Current
strength
Old
strength
USSR
46 Panzer Corps 104 103


38 Infantry Corps 22 35 177 136 30 Infantry Army
1 Flieger Corps 218 60


56 Panzer Corps 104 92 135 66 56 Infantry Army
35 Infantry Corps 94 88 134 104 43 Infantry Army

Also not much of a line change, but the strength difference is serious. I'm going to need to push my numbers advantage here to encircle and cut them off from supplies.

 

Smolensk:

Axis Old
strength x2
Current
strength
Current
strength
Old
strength
USSR
7 Infantry Corps 58 33


1 Infantry Corps 62 29


26 Infantry Corps 82 62


13 Infantry Corps 108 91


4 Flieger Corps 118 88


47 Panzer Corps 102 118 34 69 22 Infantry Army
6 Infantry Corps 107 36


34 Infantry Corps 96 80



We took an unguarded Smolensk during the start of October, cutting off the lone infantry there from supplies. The Russians are trying to take it back, and the severely weakened infantry they sent are joined by a severely weakened tank unit from the south and a strong infantry from the north. But it won't be enough.

 

Minsk:

Axis Old
strength x2
Current
strength
Current
strength
Old
strength
USSR
24 Panzer Corps 78 111 20 41 2 Tank Army
8 Infantry Corps 109 46 41 89 40 Infantry Army
2 Flieger Corps 183 106 45 79 21 Infantry Army



22 21 14 Infantry Army
 

Pathetic. Minsk will hold, but going after the Soviets in the river will be annoying.


Orel:


Axis Old
strength x2
Current
strength
Current
strength
Old
strength
USSR
9 Infantry Corps 108 45


11 Infantry Corps 91 30 138
54 Infantry Army
27 Infantry Corps 77 11 186 94 60 Infantry Army
12 Infantry Corps 97 30 47
50 Infantry Army



202
61 Infantry Army


My guys mostly marched here in the mud and snow unimpeded from northern Ukraine but are too exhausted to fight despite being positioned for multiple pincer attacks. I can only hope supplies reach them before the Soviets break out.

 

Kiev:

 

Axis Old
strength x2
Current
strength
Current
strength
Old
strength
USSR
5 Infantry Corps 92 46 35 42 18 Infantry Army
5 Flieger Corps 132 41


49 Infantry Corps 80 35
13 5 Tank Army
3 Flieger Corps 142 116



Most of these units have left Kiev by now and are moving up to Orel. Two of the units currently there came from Odessa, moving north. The Soviet 5th tank army perished trying to take Kiev back, and the 18th infantry army is about to.

 

Kharkov:

Axis Old
strength x2
Current
strength
Current
strength
Old
strength
USSR



209
39 Infantry Army
3 Panzer Corps 52 44 96 56 15 Infantry Army
4 Infantry Corps 20 21 126 113 19 Tank Army
48 Panzer Corps 148 42


14 Panzer Corps 62 58 107 114 66 Infantry Army
57 Panzer Corps 145 74


23 Infantry Corps 80 40 149 103 33 Infantry Army
29 Infantry Corps 42 21 1 41 1 Cavalry Army



174
2 Guards Infantry

Oh. Oh no.

My units here are in no fighting condition, and a battering ram of Soviets are coming in, and more are right behind them. Try not to let anyone get encircled as we withdraw west for more reliable supplies. Try not to let anyone get bashed in.

 

 Odessa:

Axis Old
strength x2
Current
strength
Current
strength
Old
strength
USSR
30 Infantry Corps 98 46


17 Infantry Corps 88 86


1 Hungarian Panzer 36 37


54 Infantry Corps 45 44


1 Rumanian Infantry 47 46


5 Rumanian Infantry 17 16


2 Rumanian Infantry 35 33


4 Italian Infantry 54 54



Odessa is now far behind all of these companies, who have regrouped and formed up with others. Russia doesn't seem all that interested in taking it back.

 

November 9 -  December 6


Northmost cluster:

Yep, the Finnish armies are still stuck there.

Axis Old
strength
Current
strength
Current
strength
Old
strength
USSR
10 Infantry Corps 31 24 48 80 9 Militia Army
28 Infantry Corps 20 38 24 36 7 Militia Army
41 Panzer Corps 83 15 40 123 11 Militia Army
40 Panzer Corps 95 95 61 82 42 Infantry Army




50 43 Infantry Army

Despite a strength advantage and a little help from the south, these minor tussles are slow. Weak, poorly supplied units can still encircle, but fighting is hard.

 

Rzhev:

Axis Old
strength
Current
strength
Current
strength
Old
strength
USSR
46 Panzer Corps 103 53


2 Infantry Corps 95 31


38 Infantry Corps 35

177 30 Infantry Army
1 Flieger Corps 60 223


56 Panzer Corps 92 85
135 56 Infantry Army
35 Infantry Corps 88 91


7 Infantry Corps 33 49



Total Soviet destruction, but not without losses on my end. Rzhev will be taken by Monday.

 

Smolensk:


Axis Old
strength
Current
strength
Current
strength
Old
strength
USSR
11 Infantry Corps 30 38
134 43 Infantry Army
26 Infantry Corps 62 9


4 Flieger Corps 88 180


1 Infantry Corps 29 56
34 22 Infantry Army
13 Infantry Corps 91 104 208
1 Guards Tank Army
47 Panzer Corps 118 58


6 Infantry Corps 36 89
20 2 Tank Army

The feeble and isolated Russian attempts to liberate Smolensk were all encircled and crushed by December. A single powerful tank army is closing in, but I've learned not to fear single armies.

 

Minsk to Orel:

Axis Old
strength
Current
strength
Current
strength
Old
strength
USSR
34 Infantry Corps 80 93


2 Flieger Corps 106 163


24 Panzer Corps 111 102
41 40 Infantry Army
8 Infantry Corps 46 101 16 22 14 Infantry Army


Minsk held, one Soviet was destroyed as we chased it across the frozen river, another is caught in a pincer on the other side of the river.

 

Orel:


Axis Old
strength
Current
strength
Current
strength
Old
strength
USSR
27 Infantry Corps 11
177 138 54 Infantry Army
12 Infantry Corps 30 51
47 50 Infantry Army
5 Infantry Corps 46 39
45 21 Infantry Army
4 Infantry Corps 21 35 236
2 Guards Cavalry
9 Infantry Corps 45 70


5 Flieger Corps 41 129 192 202 61 Infantry Army



128
45 Infantry Army

The sawtooth formation did not hold. I got two of theirs, they got one of mine. Unfortunately, they get two powerful reinforcements. At least I can count on a bit of help coming from Minsk.

 

Kiev to Kharkov:

Axis Old
strength
Current
strength
Current
strength
Old
strength
USSR
49 Infantry Corps 35 35


4 Italian Infantry 54 24


2 Rumanian Infantry 33 33


54 Infantry Corps 44 44
35 18 Infantry Army

As expected, these ragtag survivors from all over the front destroyed the sole enemy here and are marching to Kharkov.

 

Kharkov:


Axis Old
strength
Current
strength
Current
strength
Old
strength
USSR



129
47 Infantry Army
48 Panzer Corps 42 40
186 60 Infantry Army
3 Flieger Corps 116 88


17 Infantry Corps 86 65 195
9 Tank Army
3 Panzer Corps 44 62
209 39 Infantry Army
57 Panzer Corps 74 52


30 Infantry Corps 46 85


1 Hungarian Panzer 37 21 94
7 Cavalry Army
23 Infantry Corps 40
92 96 15 Infantry Army
29 Infantry Corps 21 42 130 126 19 Tank Army
5 Rumanian Infantry 16 8


1 Rumanian Infantry 46 46


14 Panzer Corps 58 22 76 107 66 Infantry Army



202
28 Tank Army



89 149 33 Infantry Army



54
95 Infantry Army



170 174 2 Guards Infantry



106
52 Infantry Army




1 1 Cavalry Army

Never forget that well-supplied Germans can punch above their weight. By withdrawing in a measured manner, I allowed multiple Soviets to spearhead and isolate themselves, letting me cut them off and destroy them piecemeal.

This still costs significant muster strength, though, which can never be recovered. And with these quickly-dwindling combat strength numbers, I'm doubting that I can outlast Soviet reinforcements!

I do, however, have an opportunity to snatch Dnepropetrovsk to the south, which is completely unguarded.

 

Overall combat strength, not counting the Finns or Fliegerkorps, comes to 1,905 now, out of 2,728 points of muster strength. Winter supply problems account for most of the difference.

Don't know if I'm going to be able to win this time!

2 comments:

  1. I am sadly a bit pre-occupied by personal events at the moment, but a small note to say I really appreciate this Expert mode AAR (even more so than the "Advanced" one with push-over Russians). I suppose I am a minority, wargames are not that popular overall.

    Also, I don't think you'll win, but you'll do much better than I did. I guess I should have tested "assault" beforehand as well. You also were smarter than I with (mostly) avoiding the marshes, though of course it meant having to later hunt down Soviets there.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm sorry to hear about that. Hope that things work out for you.

      Delete

Commenting with signin or name/URL is encouraged but not required. If the spam filter deletes your legitimate comment, apologies - it does that sometimes.

Most popular posts