Friday, November 13, 2026

NATO Commander: Chemical Ahab


 

Scenario #2, which I'm going to play on Difficult mode with Divisions is an awful lot like scenario #1. In fact, the starting units are in pretty much the same locations. The principal difference is that political points matter now, which means no more unrestricted chemical warfare.

Or does it?

Turns out there's a quirk in the original Atari version of the game. No idea if later ports fixed it.

When you order a unit to attack, you have a choice between using accelerated, regular, and chemical attacks. However, when you give the order for an accelerated attack, the engine claims you are using a chemical attack. And when you give the order for a chemical attack, the engine claims you are using a regular attack!

The "chemical attack" order does, unlike accelerated attacks, cost you political points which can shake the NATO alliance if used too much, but it is unclear to me what the actual effect of either is; only that both seem to be more effective than regular attacks. I don't know if the chemical and accelerated attack bindings got swapped, or if it's just the unit status that reports attacks incorrectly, but either way, the "accelerated attack" command seems to have little downside.


Day 1 

 

Familiar setup, familiar tactics. The Berlin Corps retreats, and I try to assemble everyone to the front. Engagement will use the mysterious, politically cheap "accelerated" attacks exclusively, but only when we can attack at a 2:1 advantage, not counting helicopters. Wings focus on air superiority today.


 

Day 2

 

Lack of recon means there are certainly any number of WP units in the fog of war between the forming column and my retreating infantry, but my wings remain focused on air superiority.

Our first ground kill is scored today near Hanover, but more armor comes.


 

EOD: 20,200 NATO casualties, no units lost. 40,700 WP casualties, 2 units destroyed. NATO Air superiority achieved, 2 cities taken by WP.

 

Day 3

  

Air wings have switched to ground support, but the first Berlin Corps is lost, and my choppers are about to be threatened.

Dutch and German reinforcements are incoming, and one East German mech division that snuck past my line heads for the other choppers - I direct some of the reinforcements to intercept.


EOD: 18,400 NATO casualties, 3 units lost. 44,300 WP casualties, 2 units destroyed. NATO sustains air superiority. 1 city retaken, Yugoslavia abandons WP.

 

Day 4


Two more NATO units are lost in the wee hours in an unsuccessful encircling maneuver, but Moscow folds this day in spite of materiel gains.

 

Scenario stats:

NATO losses: 49,200 troops, 1,034 tanks.

WP losses: 117,900 troops, 2,874 tanks.

3% of Germany penetrated, 2 cities overrun.

Final score: 23,450.


This outcome, by the way, completely blows away my performance in the last scenario in every regard, and without the huge benefit to frontage that Brigades mode provides. Therefore, I wonder if Meier might have not only accidentally swapped the Accelerated and Chemical attack function keys, but also assigned the political points loss function to the wrong attack type.

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Game 480: NATO Commander


I've been putting this one off for a bit, being a Sid Meier game from 1983 that predates two whales that I already covered. I rationalized this by telling myself that NATO Commander isn't really an ancestor to F-15 Strike Eagle or Silent Service. As a wargame, it made way more sense to treat it as an ancestor to Crusade in Europe and put it off for that one. But the truth is, I didn't really want to play it. Abstract wargames aren't really my thing, NATO Commander isn't especially celebrated among Meier's oeuvre, Wargaming Scribe ranked it as among his least loved games (for reference, his AAR+Review), and to me, the game is an unreadable eyesore. And it gets worse in motion.

 

This game is realtime with pause, and the "with pause" aspect becomes critically important, because there's no way you can keep up with the action otherwise. In fact, even attempting to give orders or query units when it isn't paused is futile, not just because of the relentless pace but because the inputs lag whenever anything is going on.

I found myself pausing every few ingame hours or whenever an event caught my attention, and then while paused, re-evaluate the situation and query every single unit to ensure that they are still under sensible orders. Because orders from mere seconds ago can quickly become forgotten or become counterproductive, like logjams of units now trying to cross impassible terrain or into the same spot, or units attacking the empty space where an enemy used to be. But the pause doesn't help at all with the barrage of messages that come and go faster than I can read them.

NATO Commander offers five scenarios, with four difficulties and two operational modes; Divisions and Brigades. The latter is intended to give you finer control over the armies, with smaller, more numerous units, but in reality this completely changes the gameplay dynamic since only one unit can be contained in a hex regardless of size.

 

For this first post, I'll be playing the first scenario with brigades, on the second-hardest difficulty. I've already played a successful round on moderate and found it too easy. Here, the Warsaw Pact has launched a surprise attack on Germany, and your only objective is to inflict maximum casualties as quickly as possible. Or to use the Pentagon's doctrinal language, lethality-maxxing. Territory loss does not matter, and there is no diplomatic penalty for employing chemical weapons, so I will of course be using them exclusively.

 

Day 1 


There's a lot of colors on the map, but all that really matters is that orange units are Warsaw Pact and everyone else is NATO. The Berlin Corps, marked by the cluster of three blue infantry units on the eastern side, are in trouble.

The goal for the day - hastily withdraw the Berlin Corps, mobilize the Netherlands cavalry brigades far out west, and bring everyone else into a defensive column about where the frontmost of my two helicopter companies is. The airforce will be on reconnaissance. Air units do not move in this game, but helicopters can strike anywhere on the map, wings can be assigned recon or support duties, and SAM and airfields provide passive bonuses to your air superiority as long as they are not overrun by ground forces.

Nighttime progress. Contact near Hanover. Berlin took a beating. Minimal engagement otherwise.

 

 

Day 2

 

The column is forming nicely in the north, and just in time - a large East German mechanized infantry division is engaged, and we break to encircle and destroy. Same for the armor further south, who we are already fighting, with full air support including helicopters. The Berlin Corps, hurting bad but disengaged from combat for now, is fleeing west to join up with the rest, and the Dutch cavalry are still slogging through the marshes.

1200: Polish dock workers strike in protest (this is good).

1400: First Berlin Corps surrenders to pursuing armor division.

1500: Routed British mech brigade surrenders.

2100: Soviet armor destroyed near Hanover. Helicopters refocused on partially-encircled East German infantry division, who are soon destroyed after.

EOD: 19,800 NATO casualties, 26,500 WP casualties.

 

Day 3


 

Hanover is taken, and two large mech divisions are in sight, but my defense column is strong and they won't cause too much trouble. What's left of the Berlin corps is part of it, and the Dutch cavalry inch closer to the line, and West German reinforcements have mobilized but are too far away from the action to be all that useful right now.

Air force continues to focus on ground support despite some MiG resistance. Another mech division is destroyed during the day, but shock reinforcements crash against my wall.


The precise order of the day's events were difficult to keep track of, but by midnight, spies were reporting mass desertions in the Czech army.

 

Day 4

 

Some of the Dutch units have arrived, tired from the three day march, and the West German militia are in sight. Five WP armor units and one infantry are engaged as I do my best to encircle and destroy them, and am successful in eliminating two.

Yugoslavia withdraws by the end of the day.


Day 5

For the first time, all of my units are on a single screen.
 

The WP advance is halted, but my air force is starting to lose effectiveness. But it doesn't matter; despite some concentrated attacks on my southern flank, they are running out of steam and they know it.

You have to reboot the computer to play another scenario.

 

This victory was, by the way, significantly more decisive than my first go on moderate difficulty. It goes to show that if you're willing to meet the micromanagement-heavy demands of Brigade mode, you can grind the Soviets into blutwurst. I don't think I'll do that again.

So far, I don't hate this game quite as much as I expected to, but the many UI problems and somewhat poor battle result feedback do make it a tedious experience. I will note that Eastern Front 1941 had similar and arguably even worse feedback issues, but that game was more or less turn-based and had an extremely elegant UI that enabled complex unit pathing, which is impossible here.

Most popular posts